Potbelly Sandwich Shop Menu With Prices, Calories & Guide November 2026
At Potbelly, most sandwiches run between about $7.49 and $11.99, while cookies and small sides sit at the low end and large shakes and catering trays at the top. A cookie at around $2.49 is usually the cheapest single item on the board. Shops generally open near 10 or 11 in the morning and close around 8 or 9 at night, with lunch the busiest stretch and dinner service lighter.
Potbelly built its reputation on one thing above all else: sandwiches toasted until the bread turns crisp and the cheese melts through the filling. The shop started as a small Chicago antique store that sold toasted sandwiches to keep customers around, and the warm, toasty sandwich is still the heart of the menu today. Regulars come for the crunch of the toasted roll, the generous fillings and the cookies baked in the shop, all in a casual setting that feels more like a neighbourhood deli than a fast-food counter.
The chain began in Chicago, Illinois, in 1977 and now runs about 400 shops across the United States, mostly in city centres, suburbs and near universities. Because many shops sit in busy downtown areas, opening and closing times drift a bit from one shop to the next, so treat the hours here as the usual pattern, not a guarantee for your local shop. The location finder on the official site is the fastest way to check the shop nearest you.
The prices in this guide are typical figures taken from Potbelly’s ordering pages and public menu listings reviewed in November 2026, not a fixed national list. Expect the same sandwich to cost a dollar more in a downtown shop than in a suburban one, and delivery orders usually run higher once fees are added. Seasonal items also appear and disappear without notice, so use these numbers to sketch out a budget and double-check the final total on the board or in the app before paying, remembering that tax is added on top.
Originals (A Wreck, Italian & Turkey)
The Originals are the sandwiches Potbelly is known for, and A Wreck sits at the top of that list. It stacks salami, roast beef, turkey and ham with Swiss cheese, and the combination of four meats gives it a salty, hearty flavour that no single-meat sandwich matches. The Italian follows a similar idea with salami, capicola, mortadella and provolone, while the Turkey Breast keeps things lighter with sliced turkey, Swiss and a mild dressing.
All three come toasted on a roll that the shop bakes in-house, and you can pick the regular or the larger Big size depending on your appetite. The toppings are simple, usually lettuce, tomato, onion and a choice of hot peppers or mayonnaise, which lets the meat and cheese do most of the work. If you have never eaten here, A Wreck is the order that shows you what the shop is about in a single sandwich.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| A Wreck (Regular) | $8.99–$9.99 | 720 | Four meats, Swiss cheese |
| A Wreck (Big) | $10.99–$11.99 | 1020 | Larger portion, more meat |
| Italian (Regular) | $8.49–$9.49 | 690 | Salami, capicola, provolone |
| Italian (Big) | $10.49–$11.49 | 980 | Larger Italian sandwich |
| Turkey Breast (Regular) | $7.99–$8.99 | 560 | Sliced turkey, Swiss cheese |
| Turkey Breast (Big) | $9.99–$10.99 | 820 | Larger turkey sandwich |
| Mediterranean (Regular) | $8.49–$9.49 | 620 | Feta, hummus, vegetables |
| Mediterranean (Big) | $10.49–$11.49 | 900 | Larger vegetarian option |
Pro Diner Tip: order A Wreck in the regular size first, because the Big is a lot of food for one sitting, and ask for hot peppers if you like a little heat, since they cut through the richness of the four meats.
Value analysis: the Turkey Breast is the cheapest Original and the lightest, while A Wreck costs about a dollar more for a much heartier sandwich, so A Wreck is the better buy when you are genuinely hungry and turkey is the better buy for a lighter lunch.
Hot Sandwiches
Hot sandwiches at Potbelly are toasted longer and built around warm fillings, which gives them a different character from the cold-cut Originals. The meatball sandwich leads the group, with marinara sauce and melted provolone over meatballs on a toasted roll, and it tastes closer to a sit-down Italian sub than a deli sandwich. The grilled chicken and the tuna melt cover the lighter end of the hot range, while a roast beef and cheddar option suits anyone who wants something warm and filling.
Because these sandwiches are served hot, the cheese melts into the bread and the fillings stay warm through the whole meal, which makes them a good pick in colder weather. They cost about the same as the Originals, so the choice comes down to mood rather than money. If you are ordering to go, the hot sandwiches hold their heat well for the drive home, although the bread softens a little in the wrapper.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meatball Sandwich (Regular) | $8.49–$9.49 | 760 | Meatballs, marinara, provolone |
| Meatball Sandwich (Big) | $10.49–$11.49 | 1060 | Larger meatball sandwich |
| Grilled Chicken Sandwich | $8.99–$9.99 | 640 | Grilled chicken, cheddar, mayo |
| Tuna Melt | $8.49–$9.49 | 700 | Tuna salad, melted cheddar |
| Roast Beef & Cheddar | $8.99–$9.99 | 680 | Warm roast beef, cheddar |
| Chicken Pesto Sandwich | $9.49–$10.49 | 720 | Chicken, pesto, provolone |
| Grilled Cheese Sandwich | $6.49–$7.49 | 620 | Melted cheese on toasted bread |
| BLT Sandwich | $7.49–$8.49 | 580 | Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo |
Pro Diner Tip: eat the meatball sandwich straight away while the cheese is still melted, because it cools faster than the cold-cut sandwiches, and ask for the marinara on the lighter side if you are taking it to go.
Value analysis: the grilled cheese is the cheapest hot sandwich and a fair light lunch, while the meatball sandwich costs about two dollars more for a much bigger meal, so the meatball wins when you want a full dinner and the grilled cheese wins for a quick snack.
Chicken Sandwiches
Chicken sandwiches at Potbelly cover both grilled and breaded styles, so there is a version for almost every taste. The grilled chicken sandwich keeps things simple with a chicken breast, cheddar and mayonnaise on a toasted roll, while the breaded chicken version adds a crisp coating and a little more crunch. A buffalo chicken sandwich brings a spicy sauce into the mix for guests who like heat, and the chicken salad sandwich offers a cooler, creamier alternative.
The chicken here is cooked to order and sliced or served whole depending on the sandwich, which keeps it from drying out the way pre-cooked chicken often does. Prices sit in the same band as the Originals, so chicken is a lateral move rather than a premium one. If you are choosing between chicken and the meat Originals, the grilled chicken is the lighter pick and the breaded version is the more indulgent one.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grilled Chicken Sandwich (Regular) | $8.99–$9.99 | 640 | Grilled chicken, cheddar, mayo |
| Breaded Chicken Sandwich | $8.99–$9.99 | 720 | Crispy breaded chicken breast |
| Buffalo Chicken Sandwich | $9.49–$10.49 | 740 | Spicy buffalo sauce, ranch |
| Chicken Salad Sandwich | $8.49–$9.49 | 660 | Creamy chicken salad, lettuce |
| Chicken Pesto Sandwich | $9.49–$10.49 | 720 | Chicken, pesto, provolone |
| Grilled Chicken (Big) | $10.99–$11.99 | 920 | Larger grilled chicken sandwich |
| Chicken Club Sandwich | $9.99–$10.99 | 780 | Chicken, bacon, cheddar, mayo |
Pro Diner Tip: pick the grilled chicken if you want the lightest sandwich on the board, and try the buffalo version once, because the spicy sauce and ranch dressing together give it a flavour the plain chicken sandwiches do not have.
Value analysis: the chicken salad sandwich is the cheapest chicken option and a solid lunch, while the chicken club costs about a dollar and a half more for bacon and extra filling, so the club is worth it only when you want the heartiest chicken sandwich available.
Soups
Soup at Potbelly is a daily rotation rather than a fixed list, and the board at your local shop will show what is cooking that day. Broccoli cheddar is the regular favourite, thick and creamy with a mild cheese flavour, while chicken noodle and tomato soups appear most days as well. Chilli shows up in the colder months, and a baked potato soup rounds out the rotation when the season turns.
Soups come in a cup or a bowl, and a bowl with a half sandwich makes a popular lunch combination for guests who want something warm without a full sandwich. The cup is also a good add-on to a regular sandwich when you want a little extra without ordering a second main. Ask what is on the board before you order, because the daily soup can sell out by the late afternoon.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Broccoli Cheddar Soup (Cup) | $3.49–$4.49 | 280 | Creamy, most popular soup |
| Broccoli Cheddar Soup (Bowl) | $4.99–$5.99 | 420 | Full serving, meal size |
| Chicken Noodle Soup (Cup) | $3.49–$4.49 | 200 | Chicken, noodles, vegetables |
| Chicken Noodle Soup (Bowl) | $4.99–$5.99 | 300 | Lighter soup option |
| Tomato Soup (Cup) | $3.49–$4.49 | 240 | Smooth tomato soup |
| Tomato Soup (Bowl) | $4.99–$5.99 | 360 | Pairs well with grilled cheese |
| Chilli (Cup) | $3.99–$4.99 | 320 | Seasonal, beef and beans |
| Baked Potato Soup (Bowl) | $4.99–$5.99 | 440 | Creamy potato soup, seasonal |
Pro Diner Tip: pair a bowl of tomato soup with the grilled cheese sandwich, because the combination costs less than a full sandwich meal and tastes like a classic deli lunch, and order the cup when you are adding soup to a sandwich rather than replacing it.
Value analysis: a cup of chicken noodle soup is the cheapest warm item on the menu, and a bowl of broccoli cheddar plus a half sandwich is one of the best-value lunches here, beating a full sandwich with a side by a dollar or two.
Salads
Salads at Potbelly are built on the same ingredients as the sandwiches, which means the flavours will feel familiar even if the format is different. The garden salad covers the basics with mixed greens, tomato, cucumber and onion, while the chicken-topped salads add grilled chicken for a main-dish portion. A Mediterranean salad with feta and hummus covers the vegetarian side, and the dressings range from a light vinaigrette to a creamy ranch.
The salads are a good choice for anyone who wants the Potbelly flavours without the bread, and the portions are generous enough to work as a full lunch. Dressing comes on the side when you ask, which keeps the calories close to the listed figures. If you are eating with a sandwich lover, a salad and a shared cookie make a balanced table without doubling the bread.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Garden Salad | $6.49–$7.49 | 280 | Greens, tomato, cucumber, onion |
| Garden Salad with Chicken | $9.49–$10.49 | 480 | Adds grilled chicken |
| Chicken Caesar Salad | $9.99–$10.99 | 560 | Romaine, parmesan, croutons, chicken |
| Mediterranean Salad | $8.49–$9.49 | 460 | Feta, hummus, vegetables |
| Farmhouse Salad | $9.49–$10.49 | 520 | Chicken, egg, bacon, cheese |
| Side Salad | $3.49–$4.49 | 160 | Small salad with any sandwich |
| Caesar Salad (no chicken) | $6.99–$7.99 | 380 | Romaine, parmesan, croutons |
Pro Diner Tip: ask for the dressing on the side and add the chicken to the garden salad instead of ordering the pre-built chicken salad, because the result is similar and you control how much dressing goes on.
Value analysis: the plain garden salad is the cheapest salad by a clear margin, while the chicken Caesar costs about three dollars more for a full meal, so the garden salad suits a side order and the chicken Caesar suits a main dish.
Kids Meals
Potbelly’s kids meals are built for small appetites and short attention spans: a half sandwich, a grilled cheese or a little chicken sandwich, always with a side and a drink. Turkey and ham are the usual picks, and the portions are sized so a child can finish without leaving half the plate behind. Parents ordering for two children can usually add a cookie to share without stretching the bill.
Each kids meal pairs the sandwich with a side and a drink, and the whole meal generally lands between five and seven dollars, which undercuts most sit-down restaurants for a family lunch. Staff will happily hold the sauce or put it in a small cup for children who prefer plain food, and a shop-baked cookie makes a popular finish if your child still has room. Choice is limited to a handful of sandwiches, yet the options cover the flavours children ask for most often.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kids Turkey Sandwich Meal | $5.49–$6.49 | 420 | Half sandwich, side, drink |
| Kids Ham Sandwich Meal | $5.49–$6.49 | 440 | Half sandwich, side, drink |
| Kids Grilled Cheese Meal | $4.99–$5.99 | 480 | Grilled cheese, side, drink |
| Kids Chicken Sandwich Meal | $5.99–$6.99 | 520 | Small chicken sandwich, side, drink |
| Kids PB&J Meal | $4.49–$5.49 | 460 | Peanut butter and jelly, side, drink |
| Kids Side: Apple Slices | $1.29–$1.79 | 35 | Fresh apple slices instead of chips |
| Kids Drink: Milk or Juice | $1.49–$1.99 | 110 | Milk or juice with the meal |
Pro Diner Tip: ask for apple slices in place of chips if your child likes fruit, since the kitchen usually makes that swap for free, and choose milk over soda to keep the meal lighter at no extra cost.
Value analysis: the PB&J meal undercuts every other kids meal by a dollar or so and still satisfies a younger appetite, while the chicken sandwich meal charges roughly a dollar extra for a more filling protein, so the chicken is the smarter pick for older children.
Sides
Sides at Potbelly are short and focused, which suits a menu built around big sandwiches. Potato chips are the standard partner for a toasted sandwich, with a few flavours on the shelf, and a pickle spear comes with most sandwiches at no extra charge. A side salad and a cup of soup cover the lighter and warmer alternatives, and a bag of chips is also the cheapest way to round out a sandwich-only order.
The sides are meant to complete the sandwich rather than compete with it, so the portions stay modest. A bag of chips adds crunch and salt for about two dollars, while a side salad adds freshness for about a dollar more. If you are ordering for the table, one side salad shared between two people works better than two separate bags of chips.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Potato Chips (Bag) | $1.99–$2.49 | 220 | Standard sandwich side |
| Kettle Chips (Bag) | $2.49–$2.99 | 240 | Thicker, crunchier chips |
| Pickle Spear | $0.99–$1.49 | 10 | Often included with sandwich |
| Side Salad | $3.49–$4.49 | 160 | Lighter side option |
| Cup of Soup (side) | $3.49–$4.49 | 200–280 | Warm side, ask daily flavour |
| Coleslaw (side) | $2.49–$2.99 | 180 | Creamy slaw, where offered |
| Fruit Cup | $2.99–$3.49 | 90 | Fresh fruit side |
Pro Diner Tip: stick with the regular chips instead of the kettle version when you are watching the bill, since the difference is mostly texture, and a side salad is the better pick when your sandwich already has plenty of salt and fat.
Value analysis: the pickle spear is the cheapest side on the board, while the bag of chips is the best-value filling side at about two dollars, and the side salad only makes financial sense when you want freshness rather than crunch.
Shakes & Desserts
Dessert at Potbelly leans on two signatures: cookies baked in the shop and hand-dipped shakes made with real ice cream. The cookies come in chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, sugar and a rotating seasonal flavour, and they are baked through the day so a warm cookie is often available. The shakes are thick, made with vanilla, chocolate or strawberry ice cream, and they pair naturally with a salty sandwich in the way only a deli shake can.
The cookie is the cheapest sweet on the menu and the one most regulars add to a sandwich order, while the shake is a meal in itself for anyone with a big appetite. A shake and a cookie together make a fair dessert for two people to share, and the cookie also travels well if you want something sweet for later. Seasonal cookies rotate through the year, so the board may carry a flavour that is not listed here.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Chocolate Chip Cookie | $2.49 | 430 | Baked in shop, most ordered |
| Oatmeal Raisin Cookie | $2.49 | 400 | Chewy oatmeal cookie |
| Sugar Cookie | $2.49 | 410 | Plain sweet cookie |
| Seasonal Cookie | $2.49–$2.99 | 420 | Rotating flavour, ask locally |
| Hand-Dipped Shake (Small) | $4.49–$4.99 | 560 | Vanilla, chocolate or strawberry |
| Hand-Dipped Shake (Regular) | $5.49–$5.99 | 740 | Standard shake size |
| Hand-Dipped Shake (Large) | $6.49–$6.99 | 920 | Sharing or very thirsty size |
| Cookie & Shake Combo | $6.99–$7.49 | 1150 | Small shake plus one cookie |
Pro Diner Tip: choose the small shake alongside a sandwich, since the regular size on its own can feel like a second meal, and pick a cookie that has just left the oven when you can, because the warmth makes a real difference.
Value analysis: a cookie at $2.49 is the cheapest sweet here by a clear margin, while the large shake costs close to fifty percent more than the small for a serving most people end up sharing, so the small shake is the sensible solo choice.
Beverages
Drinks at Potbelly cover the usual sandwich-shop range, from fountain sodas and iced tea to lemonade, coffee and bottled water. Fountain drinks come in small, regular and large, with refills on dine-in drinks at many shops, though that policy varies by location. Lemonade, including a strawberry version at many shops, offers a sweeter alternative that pairs well with the spicy sandwiches.
Hot coffee gets more attention here than at many sandwich shops, since the doors open mid-morning and early lunch guests often want something warm alongside a toasted sandwich. Sealed bottles and cartons of milk suit anyone who would rather skip the fountain, and chocolate milk stays a favourite with younger diners. Drinks are among the cheapest things on the board, so adding one to a sandwich order rarely costs more than a couple of dollars extra.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fountain Drink (Small) | $2.29–$2.79 | 150 | Soda or iced tea |
| Fountain Drink (Regular) | $2.59–$3.09 | 200 | Middle size, pairs with sandwiches |
| Fountain Drink (Large) | $3.09–$3.59 | 280 | Biggest cup on the menu |
| Fresh-Brewed Coffee | $1.99–$2.49 | 5 | Hot morning drink |
| Iced Tea | $2.49–$2.99 | 90 | Sweetened or unsweetened |
| Lemonade | $2.59–$3.09 | 180 | Strawberry version at many shops |
| Milk or Chocolate Milk | $1.99–$2.49 | 150 | Good with kids meals |
| Bottled Water | $1.89–$2.39 | 0 | Sealed bottle of water |
| Bottled Juice | $2.59–$3.09 | 130 | Apple or orange, bottled |
Pro Diner Tip: order the small coffee with your morning sandwich, since the larger cup mostly adds volume rather than flavour, and check whether your shop offers dine-in refills before you pay for another drink.
Value analysis: the small coffee gives the best return of any hot drink here, while the large fountain cup costs nearly half as much again as the small one, so the small is the smart choice unless you are sharing.
Catering & Group Orders
Catering at Potbelly is built around sandwich trays, and it suits office lunches, study groups and family gatherings where everyone wants a different sandwich. A tray of assorted sandwiches feeds roughly eight to ten people, and the order usually includes chips, cookies and drinks when you ask for a full package. Big orders need a heads-up, so ringing the shop the day before keeps everything on schedule.
Box lunches shrink the same idea down to one person, giving each guest a sandwich with chips, a cookie and a drink in a single box. They run slightly dearer per head than a shared tray, but they spare the host from working out who eats what, which helps when the lunch is also a meeting. Many shops will bring catering orders to your door, and the delivery charge varies with how far away you are and how much food you ordered.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sandwich Tray (serves 8–10) | $74.99–$84.99 | 5600 | Assorted sandwiches, about $8–$10 per person |
| Sandwich Tray (serves 12–15) | $109.99–$119.99 | 8400 | Larger tray for a bigger group |
| Box Lunch (per person) | $11.49–$12.99 | 980 | Sandwich, chips, cookie, drink |
| Salad Bowl (serves 8–10) | $44.99–$49.99 | 3800 | Large salad for the group |
| Soup by the Quart | $12.99–$14.99 | 1120 | Serves about four bowls |
| Cookie Tray (12 cookies) | $24.99–$27.99 | 5160 | Dessert tray for a group |
| Cookie Tray (24 cookies) | $44.99–$49.99 | 10320 | Larger dessert tray |
| Shake by the Quart | $14.99–$16.99 | 2240 | Serves about four small shakes |
Pro Diner Tip: pick the mixed sandwich tray when your group has varied tastes, since it keeps the per-head cost down and covers the popular fillings, and agree a collection time when you book so the sandwiches arrive warm.
Value analysis: the sandwich tray works out to roughly eight to ten dollars per person, noticeably cheaper than ordering the same sandwiches individually, while the box lunch costs more per person but saves the host time, so the tray wins for a casual group and the box lunch wins for a formal meeting.
Current Deals & Value Picks
The sharpest Potbelly savings live in the rewards app rather than on the menu board, where rotating bundles and member-only offers change through the year. Every order earns points that can be swapped for a free sandwich, a free cookie or a free shake, and the app adds birthday treats and discounts you will not see on the wall. Joining usually brings a free cookie or a first-order discount, so it pays to sign up before you walk in.
Day to day, the best-value orders are the regular Turkey Breast sandwich, a grilled cheese with tomato soup and a shop-baked cookie, each landing near or below nine dollars. The app or the website lists the offers running at your own shop, and those offers shift from one area to another. For a wider look at lunch pricing at other chains, see the lunch menu guide on Menu Price Wise, while the Menu Price Wise homepage lists every guide we publish. If you want to weigh up other sandwich shops, the Subway menu with prices, the Panera Bread menu with prices or the Arby’s menu with prices are all handy for comparing.
| Item | Price | Calories | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Turkey Breast (Regular) | $7.99–$8.99 | 560 | Best-value sandwich |
| Grilled Cheese Sandwich | $6.49–$7.49 | 620 | Cheapest hot sandwich |
| A Wreck (Regular) | $8.99–$9.99 | 720 | Best-value hearty sandwich |
| Broccoli Cheddar Soup (Cup) | $3.49–$4.49 | 280 | Cheapest warm starter |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie | $2.49 | 430 | Cheapest dessert |
| Potato Chips (Bag) | $1.99–$2.49 | 220 | Cheapest filling side |
| Kids PB&J Meal | $4.49–$5.49 | 460 | Cheapest kids meal |
Pro Diner Tip: download the rewards app before you order for the first time, since a handful of ordinary visits earns enough points for a free sandwich, and glance at the app before each trip to catch the latest free-cookie or discount offer.
Value analysis: the best everyday orders stand on their own without any coupon, because the Turkey Breast, the grilled cheese and the cookie are fairly priced as they are, and the rewards points only push an already fair meal a little lower. The official source for location menus and ordering is Potbelly official site.
FAQs
How much is A Wreck at Potbelly?
A Wreck typically costs around $8.99 to $9.99 in the regular size and about $10.99 to $11.99 in the Big size, depending on the location. The regular sandwich carries roughly 720 calories on its own.
What is the cheapest item on the Potbelly menu?
A pickle spear at around $0.99 to $1.49 is usually the cheapest thing on the board, with a bag of potato chips next at about $1.99 to $2.49. For dessert, a cookie runs around $2.49, and the cheapest full sandwich is the grilled cheese at roughly $6.49 to $7.49.
What time does Potbelly open and close?
A typical Potbelly shop opens near 10 or 11 in the morning and shuts around 8 or 9 in the evening, and midday is when the queue is longest. Because hours shift from one shop to another, look up your nearest shop on the official site before you set off.
Does Potbelly bake its cookies in the shop?
Yes, Potbelly bakes its cookies in the shop through the day, in flavours such as chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, sugar, plus a rotating seasonal flavour. A warm cookie straight from the oven is a regular favourite, and cookies cost about $2.49 each.
Does Potbelly have a rewards programme?
Yes, Potbelly runs a points programme inside its app: every order earns points that can be swapped for a free sandwich, a free cookie or a free shake. Members also get discounts that are only in the app, plus a birthday treat, and first-time members often receive a discount on their opening order.
How much is a Potbelly sandwich and chips meal?
A regular sandwich at about $7.99 to $9.99 plus a bag of chips at roughly $1.99 to $2.49 and a small fountain drink at about $2.19 to $2.69 brings a typical meal to around $12 to $15 before tax. A box lunch with the same pieces costs about $11.49 to $12.99 per person.
Treat every figure on this page as a guide range, not a promise from one particular shop, and check the price, the hours and the offers running that day at your local Potbelly before ordering. Dishes and deals vary with the shop and the season, delivery orders usually cost more than eating in, and the calorie counts are approximate numbers taken from the chain’s published nutrition details where those exist. Updated: November 2026.
